Why size matters more than edge in an evaluation
Sizing up gets you to the target sooner, so under a time limit it often raises the pass rate. It raises the chance of a breach with it, and it raises the pass rate of a trader with no edge at all. The sizing table puts those columns side by side so you can see how much of a higher pass rate is just a bigger bet.
A single backtest is one path through your trades. The random start date explainer shows the same problem for equity curves, and the position size calculator turns a dollar risk into a share count.
Frequently asked questions
How are the pass odds estimated?
Your trading days are resampled with replacement (trades from the same day stay together, in order) to build thousands of possible evaluation attempts. Each attempt is played against the rules you enter until it reaches the profit target, breaches the daily loss or max drawdown limit, or runs out of time. The pass odds are the share of attempts that reach the target inside the rules.
What does "constraint satisfaction, not profit maximisation" mean?
An evaluation does not reward the most profit. It rewards reaching a modest target without touching a limit. A strategy that makes more money with bigger swings can have worse pass odds than a smaller, steadier one, which is why the tool also shows the largest position size that keeps the chance of breaching a limit under the budget you set.
Is my trade data stored?
No. The CSV is read in your browser and only the numbers (P&L or R, and optional day and MAE) are sent to the simulator. The server processes them in memory for that one request and keeps nothing: no database row, no cache, no log of your trades.
Why is there a "luck" baseline?
A trader with no edge still passes some evaluations, because a random walk can hit the target before the drawdown floor. The luck baseline runs the same simulation with each trade’s sign flipped at random, so you can see how much of your pass rate is skill and how much the rules would give anyone with your trade sizes.
Which firm rules should I use?
Use the current terms of the evaluation you are considering. Firms change their targets, drawdown types and consistency rules often, so the tool has no built-in firm presets. If your firm’s time limit is in calendar days, convert it to the number of days you actually trade.