Why costs matter more for a thin edge
Every trade has two sides, and each side pays commission, crosses part of the spread and gives up some price to slippage. Those costs are charged whether the trade wins or loses. When the average gross profit per trade is small, the cost of both sides can be the same size, and the average net result is then zero or below.
The arithmetic is simple: net per trade = gross profit per trade - 2 x cost per side. Break-even cost per side = gross profit per trade / 2. A strategy that trades more often pays that cost more often, so the net per year is net per trade x trades per year.
Costs are only one input. To see how many trades it takes before an average result stands out from luck, use the how many trades calculator. To size a position from a stop, use the position size calculator, and to check a payoff, the risk/reward calculator.
Frequently asked questions
What counts as cost per side?
Everything you pay each time you enter or exit: broker commission and fees, half the bid-ask spread (you cross half of it on each side), and slippage, the gap between the price you expected and the price you got. A round trip has two sides, so the calculator doubles the number you enter.
How is the break-even cost calculated?
Net per trade is gross profit minus two times the cost per side. Setting that to zero gives a break-even cost per side of half the gross profit per trade. If the gross profit is zero or negative there is no cost level that breaks even.
Why does the table use 1.5x, 2x and 5x?
Costs you estimate are often lower than the costs you pay, especially in fast markets or with larger orders. Re-running the same arithmetic at higher costs shows how much room a thin gross edge has. The multiples are a way to look at the arithmetic, not a prediction of your costs.
Is anything I type stored or sent?
No. The calculation runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is uploaded or stored.
Does this tell me whether a strategy works?
No. It is arithmetic on numbers you supply. It cannot tell you whether the gross profit per trade is real or will continue, only what costs do to a number once you have one.